Handling Income from Crop Insurance-Price Loss vs. Yield Loss

With drought and floods in 2017, farmers affected in those areas are asking questions about the income tax treatment of crop insurance proceeds. Some people may have sold their 2016 crop in 2017 and are concerned about the doubling up of income if they receive their crop insurance payments in 2017 as well. It is possible to defer the crop insurance income to the year following harvest, but certain criteria have to be met.

A farmer who uses the cash accounting method may elect to postpone reporting insurance proceeds on damaged crops from the year of damage to the following year if 50% or more of the crop is normally sold the year following production. This is determined on a crop-by-crop basis. It is done by making the election IRC Sec. 451(d) ­- Reg. 1.451-6 on the tax return for the year of loss.

A statement must be attached to the tax return and include the following:

• election made under IRC Sec. 451(d) and Reg. 1.451-6

• identification of the specific crop or crops destroyed or damaged

• statement that under normal conditions the crop would have been sold the following year

• identification of the cause of destruction or damage and the dates it occurred

• amount of payment received and the date each payment was received for each crop

• name of the insurance carrier or payer from whom the amounts were received

If you defer the insurance income received for one crop, you must do it for all crops for which insurance money was received. This would include any disaster money received from USDA. Crop revenue insurance guarantees a certain level of income based on yield and price.

What does the tax code allow?
Federal tax code Sec. 451(d) allows the deferral of crop insurance proceeds “received as a result of destruction or damage to crops” or the inability to plant crops because of a natural disaster. IRS has previously ruled that insurance programs that provide payments without regard to actual losses fall outside the statutory definition of destruction of damage to crops. Therefore, crop revenue insurance proceeds would not be eligible for deferral.

However, if you can prove a portion of the insurance proceeds was the direct result of crop damage due to hail, flooding, drought or some other destruction, or some portion of the proceeds was the result of damage, then that portion of the insurance proceeds should be allowed for the deferral election. The portion of the proceeds that was related to price would have to be reported as income in the year received.

For 2017, it is possible the harvest price could be lower than the spring price and a portion of the insurance proceeds will be because of price loss. You need to contact your tax professional for consultation on specific questions for your farm.

Charles Brown is the Iowa State University Extension farm management specialist in southeast Iowa. Contact him at

Source: Charles Brown, Wallaces Farmer

ProAg Quick Links

Agent Toolbox Grower Toolbox Careers

ProAg News

U.S., China Trade Deal Cannot Be Taken for Granted

In testimony last week before the Senate Finance Committee, U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer displayed a more cautious tone in describing U.S., China trade negotiations. ...

Flooding Expected to Continue as Dam Flows Raised

The likelihood of more prolonged flooding along the Missouri River increased Thursday night when the Army Corps of Engineers was forced to increase water releases from Gavins Point Dam in South Dakota....

Bill Would Give Economic Boost to 4-H, FFA Students

A recently introduced House bill would give an economic boost to young people in agriculture by allowing 4-H and FFA students aged 21 and younger to keep more of the modest income they earn. ...
Get ProAg updates via email
Your browser is out-of-date!

Update your browser to view this website correctly. Update my browser now